Article 3: In West Bengal and beyond, kill the encounter — it undermines the rule of law
Why in news: Recent police encounter killings in West Bengal and other States have renewed concerns over extrajudicial actions, police accountability and the protection of constitutional rights under India's criminal justice system.
Key Details
- Increasing police encounters: Recent incidents in West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh have raised concerns about the growing use of police force against accused persons. Uttar Pradesh recorded 17,043 encounter operations between March 2017 and May 2026, highlighting the scale of the issue.
- Threat to rule of law: Police encounters conducted outside legal procedures weaken the principle that every accused person is entitled to a fair investigation and trial. Public approval of instant punishment cannot replace constitutional due process.
- Supreme Court safeguards (2014): In People's Union for Civil Liberties v. State of Maharashtra, the Supreme Court prescribed safeguards for investigating encounter deaths. These include mandatory FIR registration, an independent investigation and a magisterial inquiry.
- Reaffirmation of accountability (2025): In Arif Md Yeasin Jwadder v. State of Assam, the Supreme Court reaffirmed that these safeguards are binding. An independent investigation cannot depend on whether the victim's family initiates legal proceedings.
- Need for police reforms: Police personnel must receive proper training in the use of force, investigation and human rights. Independent oversight, transparent investigations and stronger accountability mechanisms are essential to prevent misuse of authority.
Rising Incidents of Police Encounters
- The killing of a man accused of raping and murdering a minor girl in Uttar Dinajpur, West Bengal, has raised concerns about the growing use of police encounters.
- It was reportedly the fourth such incident in West Bengal since the BJP came to power in May.
- Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari's public defence of giving the police a free hand, particularly in cases of sexual violence, has raised questions about accountability.
- Similar incidents have occurred in other States, including Andhra Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh and Punjab.
- Official statistics recorded 17,043 police encounter operations in Uttar Pradesh between March 2017 and May 2026.
Encounters and the Rule of Law
- There is a fundamental difference between allowing police to act decisively within the law and supporting instant punishment.
- Police encounters can create an impression of quick justice, especially in cases involving serious crimes.
- However, criminal justice requires proper investigation, prosecution and trial before punishment is imposed.
- Extrajudicial killings bypass the judicial process and weaken the principle that every accused person is entitled to a fair trial.
- A culture of retribution can weaken police accountability, institutional credibility and citizens' constitutional freedoms.
Wider National Pattern and Institutional Concerns
- The Andhra Pradesh incident involving a 21-year-old accused of attacking a schoolgirl with a chainsaw revived memories of the 2019 Hyderabad rape-murder case, in which four accused persons were killed in an alleged encounter.
- An investigation cited in the passage found that the Punjab Police reported 34 encounters between November 2025 and January 2026.
- Political leaders may gain public support by presenting encounters as evidence of a tough approach to crime.
- However, such actions can weaken public trust in law enforcement and the criminal justice system.
- The growing acceptance of encounters risks creating a cycle in which police powers expand while independent accountability declines.
Supreme Court Guidelines on Police Encounters
- People's Union for Civil Liberties v. State of Maharashtra (2014): The Supreme Court laid down safeguards for investigating police encounters resulting in death.
- These safeguards include mandatory registration of an FIR, an independent investigation and a magisterial inquiry.
- The guidelines aim to ensure that police actions are examined independently and transparently.
- Arif Md Yeasin Jwadder v. State of Assam (May 2025): The Supreme Court reaffirmed that these safeguards are binding.
- The Court clarified that compliance cannot depend on whether the victim or the victim's family initiates legal proceedings.
Way Forward
- Police must be allowed to act firmly against crime, but always within the constitutional and legal framework.
- Every encounter resulting in death must be investigated through independent and transparent procedures.
- The police and investigating agencies must remain subject to judicial and institutional oversight.
- Governments should strengthen investigation, prosecution, forensic capacity and witness protection to improve conviction rates through lawful means.
- The criminal justice system must focus on the certainty, fairness and credibility of punishment, rather than the speed or public spectacle of encounters.
Conclusion
The legitimacy of the criminal justice system depends on fair investigation, impartial prosecution and judicial scrutiny, not instant punishment. Police must have the authority to maintain law and order within constitutional limits. Independent investigations, accountability and compliance with Supreme Court guidelines are essential. Protecting the rights of accused persons and victims alike strengthens public trust and ensures that justice remains governed by law.
Descriptive question:
Extrajudicial killings weaken public confidence in the criminal justice system and undermine the rule of law. Examine the constitutional and institutional safeguards governing police encounters in India and suggest measures to strengthen police accountability. (150 words, 10 marks)
Source: The Indian Express