IAS/UPSC Coaching Institute  

Article 1: Suboptimal outcomes

Why in news: The Union Labour Ministry has constituted National Social Security Boards for unorganised and gig workers, raising hopes of wider protection but concerns over centralisation and inadequate representation.

Key Details

  • New institutional mechanism: The Union Government has established two National Social Security Boards under the Code on Social Security, 2020—one for unorganised workers and another for gig and platform workers. These bodies aim to improve welfare coverage.
  • Composition and representation: The Union Labour Minister chairs both Boards. Although workers and employers have representatives, concerns remain over the limited participation of State Governments and Central Trade Unions, particularly those outside the ruling political alliance.
  • Importance of social security: The International Labour Organization defines social security as protection against risks such as illness, unemployment, old age, maternity and workplace injuries. It helps workers maintain income security and access essential services.
  • Challenges facing informal workers: Unorganised, gig and platform workers constitute over 92% of India's workforce, according to the passage. Many lack reliable access to health insurance, pensions, paid leave and protection against employment-related risks.
  • Need for cooperative governance: Labour falls under the Concurrent List, requiring cooperation between the Union and State Governments. Greater participation of trade unions, workers and State authorities can improve policy design, implementation and accountability.

Constitution of National Social Security Boards

  • The Union Labour Ministry has constituted two National Social Security Boards under the Code on Social Security.
  • One Board will focus on unorganised sector workers, while the other will address gig and platform workers.
  • The constitution of these Boards is a welcome step, although it came after a delay.
  • Their main objective is to improve social security and welfare for vulnerable workers.

Concerns over Centralisation

  • Both Boards are controlled by the Union Government and chaired by the Union Labour Minister.
  • Most members are nominated by the Centre, limiting the role of State Governments and independent trade unions.
  • Opposition-affiliated Central Trade Unions and Opposition-ruled States have limited representation.
  • This may weaken cooperative federalism and reduce the participation of workers in decision-making.
  • Since labour is in the Concurrent List, both the Centre and States must work together on labour welfare.

Meaning and Present Status of Social Security

  • The International Labour Organization (ILO) defines social security as protection that ensures access to healthcare and income security.
  • It covers risks such as old age, unemployment, sickness, disability, work injury, maternity and loss of a breadwinner.
  • The Union Government claims that India's social security coverage increased from 19% in 2015 to 64.3% in 2025, covering around 94 crore citizens.
  • However, unorganised, gig and platform workers form over 92% of India's workforce and continue to face major gaps in social protection.

Unresolved Issues and Earlier Recommendations

  • The National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganised Sector, headed by Arjun Sengupta, had recommended measures to improve informal workers' social security.
  • Many of its recommendations remain unaddressed even after nearly two decades.
  • A report prepared by Justice V. Gopala Gowda for the Keralam Government flagged concerns about the Code's impact on federalism and workers' rights.
  • It suggested amendments to address these concerns and strengthen worker protection.

Way Forward

  • The Union Government should involve Central Trade Unions and State Governments in designing social security mechanisms.
  • The representation of workers and employers should be made more meaningful.
  • Social security schemes must ensure access to healthcare, income protection and welfare benefits.
  • The Centre and States should work together to address the needs of informal, gig and platform workers.
  • The objective should be to ensure inclusive social protection and decent living standards for the vast majority of India's workforce.

Conclusion

India's social security framework must extend beyond formal employment to protect its large informal workforce. Effective implementation requires inclusive representation, adequate funding and cooperation between Union and State Governments. Gig workers and unorganised labourers need reliable access to healthcare, pensions, insurance and income protection. A decentralised and participatory approach can strengthen worker welfare, reduce economic vulnerability and promote inclusive and equitable development.

Descriptive question:

Social security is essential for ensuring dignity and economic security among India's informal workforce. Examine the challenges in extending social protection to unorganised and gig workers and discuss the role of cooperative federalism in addressing them. (150 words, 10 marks)